Benefits of 12-Step Programs for People With a Dual Diagnosis

Dual diagnosis is the term mental health professionals use to describe someone diagnosed simultaneously with drug or alcohol-related abuse/addiction and a separate mental disorder such as depression or schizophrenia. People who receive such a diagnosis face unique challenges on their road to recovery and restoration of physical/mental health. In a study published in September 2013 in the journal Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research, a multi-institution research team examined the usefulness of 12-step self-help programs in facilitating the recovery of young adults with a dual diagnosis. The members of this team concluded that, despite the extra issues involved, 12-step attendance provides a significant benefit for these individuals.

Dual Diagnosis Basics

Under current guidelines established by the American Psychiatric Association, people who abuse drugs or alcohol—o r have physical addictions to drugs or alcohol—qualify for a mental health diagnosis called a substance use disorder. For this reason, a dual diagnosis actually involves the presence of two co-existing mental disorders. However, because of the special challenges facing someone who has simultaneous abuse/addiction issues and a second mental health diagnosis, mental health professionals find value in maintaining dual diagnosis as a separate category from other forms of coexisting mental illness.

Current figures indicate that more than 50 percent of people with a drug-related substance use disorder qualify for a dual diagnosis, while roughly one-third of people with an alcohol-related substance use disorder qualify for such a diagnosis. Conversely, about 50 percent of people affected by schizophrenia or some other severe non-drug- or alcohol-related mental illness qualify for a dual diagnosis, while almost one-third of all people with a non-drug- or alcohol-related mental illness qualify for such a diagnosis.

12-Step Program Basics

Twelve-step groups get their name because they focus on 12 progressive stages or steps in the recovery process from an addiction to drugs or alcohol. Generally speaking, these groups put a high value on abstinence from drug and/or alcohol use during recovery. To help their members achieve this goal, they use an approach that emphasizes honesty regarding one’s substance-related history and current challenges, ongoing mutual support and recognition of a higher power or some sort of larger force beyond the self. Well-known 12-step groups in the U.S. include Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), Narcotics Anonymous (NA), Marijuana Anonymous (MA) and Cocaine Anonymous (CA). Two 12-step programs, called Dual Recovery Anonymous and Double Trouble in Recovery, specifically address the issues facing people with a dual diagnosis.

Current Findings

In the study published in Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research, researchers from Harvard Medical School, Massachusetts General Hospital and the Hazelden Foundation examined the effectiveness of 12-step participation for people with a dual diagnosis. They conducted this examination with the help of 296 adults between the ages of 18 and 24 enrolled in a residential treatment program for various types of substance use disorder. Over the course of a year, each of these individuals was assessed at three-month intervals on aspects of program participation such as attending sessions regularly, remaining drug- or alcohol-free, finding a sponsor, interacting with other program members and progressing through each of the program’s 12 steps.

After reviewing their findings, the authors of the study concluded that, at the start of 12-step program, people with a dual diagnosis typically have more debilitating problems than their peers who only have a substance use disorder. However, they also concluded that dual diagnosed individuals commonly show a higher level of initial motivation than their peers. In terms of program effectiveness, the authors found that people with a dual diagnosis attend their 12-step sessions just as often as people who have only a substance use disorder, and participate just as thoroughly. However, dual diagnosed individuals generally have a harder time abstaining from drugs or alcohol than their peers affected only by a substance use disorder.

Significance and Considerations

The authors of the study in Alcoholism: Clinical & Experimental Research attribute the lower abstinence rate in people with a dual diagnosis to the emotional and mental stresses of various coexisting mental disorders. However, they also note that the most thoroughly involved participants with a dual diagnosis have abstinence rates equal to those of individuals diagnosed only with a substance use disorder. In addition, they note that—despite the diminished rate of drug or alcohol abstinence for some people—as a whole, dual diagnosed individuals still gain enough benefit from 12-step programs to warrant their ongoing participation.

There is still hope.

Our licensed addiction experts can help. Call us today for a confidential assessment.


Get In Touch

If you are interested in learning more about treatment at one of our programs, please contact us by filling out the form below or calling 844-875-5609.